Skip to content

Five SF Works About Fighting Crime in Space

57
Share

Five SF Works About Fighting Crime in Space

Home / Five SF Works About Fighting Crime in Space
Blog Science Fiction

Five SF Works About Fighting Crime in Space

By

Published on May 10, 2022

Image Credit: NASA
57
Share
Image Credit: NASA

Canadians recently woke to discover that a golden age of deep space mayhem had come to an end, thanks to a clause in the 2022 federal budget. Canadian jurisdiction now extends to the stars. Thus, Canadian astronauts are no longer free to slaughter other nation’s space travellers before looting their still-warm bodies. Years of smuggling cutlasses into space have all been for naught.

Presumably some sort of jet-pack-wearing analog of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police will be along to enforce this. Its officers might well wonder “how would a space-based police force work? How does one even set fire to a barn in space?” Happily, while a space patrol may be new to Canada, SF authors have already explored how such an organization might operate, as these five vintage works prove.

 

Space Cadet by Robert Heinlein (1948)

While hardly the first space patrol novel, Heinlein’s coming-of-age tale may be one of the best known. Space Cadet follows the education and early career of would-be Interplanetary Patrolman Matt Dodson, from his enrollment to his first major assignment on Venus. Along the way, he is transformed from a naïve teen into a responsible young man.

While the Patrol reserves the option to simply nuke problems from orbit, it prefers more subtle approaches. The Venus affair is a case in point. In the 19th or 20th century, a dispute between natives and traders might have been resolved through violent retribution against the natives. The Patrol, with its more ethical and enlightened outlook, does its best to respect the Venusians and deliver actual justice. Hard news for the trader in question, who is very much in the wrong.…

 

Galactic Patrol by E. E. Smith (1937 for the magazine serial, 1950 for the novel)

The Galactic Patrol draws its candidates from all the races in galactic civilization, many of whom seem strange indeed, from a human perspective. Reconciling a bewildering diversity of cultures into one functional whole is a stupendous challenge. Good thing for civilization that not only is it being mentored (largely secretly) by the nigh-godlike Arisians, but civilization’s principal enemy is a collection of cosmic horrors against whom even Palainians seem down right neighborly.

Although he has no idea that he is the product of a secret Arisian breeding program carried out over millennia, Kimball Kinnison does know he earned his place as Patrol Lensman thanks to hard work and innate talent. He could be excused for believing himself up to any task set for him by the Patrol. His encounter with the Wheelmen, more than a match for a naïve Lensman, will prove a rude awakening.

 

Star Rangers by Andre Norton (1953)

Which races are dominant and which are subjugated have shifted and changed over the millennia—but regardless of who was in command, Central Control’s institutions have prevailed. Even star-spanning civilizations are mortal, if not as mortal as their subjects. In the year 8054, night is swiftly falling across the once-vibrant First Galactic Empire. How long the ensuing dark age will be, none can say.

The Stellar Patrol maintains Central Control’s law. The last remnant of the Patrol is by virtue of mere existence a threat to any would-be local warlord. The Stellar Patrol Scoutship Starfire is one such remnant, crewed by stalwart Patrolmen whose reward for loyalty will be a mission from which none of them are intended to return.

 

Star Cops, created by Chris Boucher (1987)

By 2027, near-Earth space has been thoroughly industrialized by the nations of Earth. Conflict is inevitable. All space-faring nations agree that there must be some agency charged with maintaining the peace. Thus, International Space Police Force is created, with the mandate of maintaining law and order…IN SPAAACE.

Nathan Spring has to be strong-armed into accepting the post as commander of the International Space Police Force. Spring is aware of the ISPF’s central contradiction: each nation wishes its rivals to be subject to the law, while none wish to be subjected to it. The so-called “star cops” are a collection of dubiously competent, questionably honest, eminently expendable no-hopers. It’s Spring’s job to somehow transform them into an effective police force.

 

Breaking Strain by Paul Preuss (1987)

Sparta has little idea whose prisoner she was before she escaped. Lest her enemies capture again, she hides. She has reinvented herself as “Ellen Troy.” Ellen Troy is a Space Board investigator. It’s a job that may or may not grant her access to information that will lead her to her former captors, but it will definitely land her in the midst of some intriguing cases.

Take the matter of the interplanetary freighter Star Queen. Stricken mid-voyage, the craft lacks enough air to sustain crewmen Grant and McNeil for the three weeks it will take to reach Venus. There is more than enough air to keep one of them alive. McNeil survives. Grant vanishes. Troy must determine how Grant came to exit Star Queen, and if the mishap that afflicted the craft was bad luck or deliberate sabotage.

***

 

No doubt many of you have your own favourites (although you might check here to make sure I did not mention them in a previous article). Comments are, as ever, below.

In the words of fanfiction author Musty181, prolific book reviewer and perennial Darwin Award nominee James Davis Nicoll “looks like a default mii with glasses.” His work has appeared in Publishers Weekly and Romantic Times as well as on his own websites, James Nicoll Reviews (where he is assisted by editor Karen Lofstrom and web person Adrienne L. Travis) and the 2021 and 2022 Aurora Award finalist Young People Read Old SFF (where he is assisted by web person Adrienne L. Travis). He is a four-time finalist for the Best Fan Writer Hugo Award, and is surprisingly flammable.

About the Author

James Davis Nicoll

Author

In the words of fanfiction author Musty181, current CSFFA Hall of Fame nominee, five-time Hugo finalist, prolific book reviewer, and perennial Darwin Award nominee James Davis Nicoll “looks like a default mii with glasses.” His work has appeared in Interzone, Publishers Weekly and Romantic Times as well as on his own websites, James Nicoll Reviews (where he is assisted by editor Karen Lofstrom and web person Adrienne L. Travis) and the 2021, 2022, 2023, and 2024 Aurora Award finalist Young People Read Old SFF (where he is assisted by web person Adrienne L. Travis). His Patreon can be found here.
Learn More About James
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
57 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
James Davis Nicoll
2 years ago

Barney Cohen’s Blood on the Moon is an odd example. A sequel to The Taking of Satcon Station, it focuses on the first mass murder on the Moon. Ideally, one would hope the detective protagonist would solve the crime or at least be solution adjacent. In this case, the protagonist gets distracted by an irrelevant side-issue and someone else solves the murder offstage.

In retrospect, I should have mentioned that not only is Nathan’s team composed of various discards and no hopers, each of them is a different national stereotype. The Australian, for example, is a criminal.

NomadUK
2 years ago

I’ll do all the easy lifting and just go right ahead and offer all of Larry Niven’s Gil Hamilton stories (eg The Patchwork Girl and The Long ARM of Gil Hamilton) and all of Isaac Asimov’s short stories featuring Wendell Urth (see Asimov’s Mysteries) — his SF equivalent of Nero Wolf — as well as The Caves of Steel and its R Daneel Olivaw sequels.

Carry on.

Michael Grosberg
Michael Grosberg
2 years ago

Glad to see there are new editions of Venus Prime with beautiful cover art, even happier to see Preuss’ name given the size it deserves on the cover. I haven’t re-read them in ages but I still remember how exciting and original they were, especially given how the *other* Clarke collab/money grubbing scheme from about the same time turned out.

templetongate
2 years ago

A more recent example is Martin L. Shoemaker‘s “Near Earth Mysteries,” which so far includes the fix-up The Last Dance, and The Last Campaign. I’m hoping there’s more in that sequence soon.

Patrick Morris Miller
2 years ago

How does one even set fire to a barn in space?

By an amazing coincidence, I was earlier this morning old when I learned what a Mr. Big operation is. 

Tim
Tim
2 years ago

 Oh, what’s that John Varley story I’m thinking of?  … “Bagatelle” featuring Anna-Louise Bach and a suicidal atomic bomb on the mooooon. I have a dim memory that there were more stories with her but I can’t bring them to mind.

vinsentient
2 years ago

Aside from the Galactic Patrol, I think the space cops series that sticks in my mind most is Space Cops by Diane Duane from the early 1990s.  I like the transplantation of police procedural to a space setting, and looking back, Duane had an excellent vision of how tablet computing could work.

SaintTherese
2 years ago

This is one of the (many) things Miles Vorkosigan does.

Cybersnark
Cybersnark
2 years ago

Of course, Doc Smith’s Galactic Patrol also directly inspired the Green Lantern Corps of DC comics (and by extension, all the other Lantern Corps).

And of course, one could argue that the United Federation of Planets’ Starfleet counts as a law enforcement organization, among its various other responsibilities (and those movie-era uniforms certainly invoke the RCMP’s style).

Robert Carnegie
2 years ago

@9: of course Captain Kirk was tasked with arresting Harry Mudd, and that shipload of hippies, and The Riddler.

I cheated deliberately to be funny.  Actor Frank Gorshin played the police officer, not the criminal.  Who would mistake one for the other?

Does anyone wonder how mirrors work on their planet?

Lesley Arrowsmith
Lesley Arrowsmith
2 years ago

Thanks for including Star Cops – I was just getting into that one when it was cancelled.  I think it could have been really good if it had a bit more time to develop.

Kedamono
Kedamono
2 years ago

Then there’s Sir Sean Connery’s movie, Outland, basically high noon in space. Notable for the use of shotguns instead of rifles. Not sure if the pellets would penetrate the habitat hull or not.

As for Star Cops, its demise was cause by a writer’s strike in 1986 that helped to seal its doom. There was a proposal for a second season, but the initial ratings of the first season pretty much killed that idea. It gained a cult following and it’s available in its entirety on YouTube.

millkill
2 years ago

In space, no one can hear you speed.

rpresser
2 years ago

#6: “The Barbie Murders” was one I enjoyed.  More about Anna-Louise Bach. And I was today years old when I learned there was a real Anna-Louise Bach. I’m not sure if Varley knew of her.

rpresser
2 years ago

Adam-Troy Castro’s Andrea Cort is a space detective. I guess that’s not exactly on topic.

E H Buchan-Kimmerly
E H Buchan-Kimmerly
2 years ago

Robert Sawyer wrote a locked door murder mystery set on a spaceship, but I can’t remember the title.

John_George
2 years ago

Okay, it’s in my mind that Hal Clement (maybe?) wrote a series of short stories about a space cop pursuing a space criminal. In each story, the space cop catches the criminal, then fate finds them in a difficult situation which only the criminal’s superior scientific knowledge would free them. The criminal makes a deal; rescue them both in exchange for a good head start. The policeman is always honorable about this, and must pursue the criminal into the next story.

One such story has them on a low-gravity world (asteroid perhaps?) on which an early alien race has put a huge concave mirror that once would have been intended as part of a powerful optical telescope. The two slip over the edge, and because the mirror surface is so low-friction, they slide back and forth, facing eventual death when their air gives out and each swing down one side and up the other takes them ten feet further from the edge.

Well, the bad guy makes the usual deal, the cop agrees because he can’t see a way out, and the bad guy and the cop hold hands and begin spinning around their common center of gravity. They swing faster and faster, and at the top of the arc, let go. The additional momentum takes them each to the lip of the ‘scope mirror, enabling them to climb out.

Of course, the bad guy carefully arranged for himself to come out on the part of the rim more conducive to a quick escape.

Does anyone else remember this series? I loved it eons ago as a kid, but now I can’t even be sure it was Hal Clement.

James Davis Nicoll
2 years ago

Not Clement but Ross Rocklynne. The Men and the Mirror, to be exact.

 

John_George
2 years ago

@18: Thank you! Now that I know which box to look in, I might be able to find it!

Clement’s Ice Planet, however, did include an alien space detective.

Lou
Lou
2 years ago

Places in the Darkness by Chris Brookmyre

wlewisiii
2 years ago

Would Outland (1981) starring Sean Connery qualify? 

wiredog
2 years ago

The Stainless Steel Rat series.

 

I got tired of the torture porn after a while though

voidampersand
2 years ago

Polar City Blues by Katharine Kerr is a police procedural on a desert planet far away in space. It mixes the feeling of classic SF with a modern sensibility, a complex fast-moving plot, engaging characters, a wide variety of aliens, and baseball. It is a real treat. 

John C. Bunnell
2 years ago

#16: That’s Golden Fleece, I think.

tim Rowledge
tim Rowledge
2 years ago

I loved Star Cops, mostly for Box. Now we have Siri.

And surely we should mention The Apollo Murders, what with it being by a Canadian astronaut and all.

Jeff Harris
Jeff Harris
2 years ago

 The earliest example of space-faring crime-fighting is Edmond Hamilton’s Tales of the Interstellar Patrol. published as a series of six novelettes in, strangely enough, Weird Tales. He managed to nip in ahead of EE ‘Doc’ Smith, a rival in space operas, in policing the spaceways.

A lesser known character engaged in crime-fighting in space is Rick Random, Space Detective. He appeared in a series of around twenty-three of what we would now call graphic novels. They were a form of comic books published in the UK as part of a series called the Super Detective Library (“Two New Issues on Sale on the First Monday of the Month!”). The series also published Rip Kirby and the masked vigilante Blackshirt to name but a few. A curious mixture of comics genres.

A number of the Rick Random stories were written by Harry Harrison. The artist Ron Turner provided a fabulous and somewhat baroque style of science-fictional art that enhanced what were often crime in space stories into SF delight. A selection of ten Rick Random stories were in an omnibus compilation published in 2008.

y2karl
y2karl
2 years ago

Jack Vance comes to mind : Kirth Gerson of the Demon Princes series or Miro Hetzel of Galactic Effectuator fame come to mind. Not to mention the fabulous Avram Davidson with his The Enquiries of Dr. Englebert Esterhazy or Masters of the Maze as examples. And too, both writers won Hugos and Edgars in their careers, let it be noted.

Marcus Rowland
Marcus Rowland
2 years ago

Two other TV series of note – the 1960s British puppet series Space Patrol had a few stories that were police operations of one sort or another, anti-piracy and so forth, though it wasn’t the main focus of the show. Gerry Anderson’s Space Precinct was exactly that, basically Hill Street Blues on an alien wold colonised by a lot of different star-faring cultures.

Clement’s Needle is another crime story of note – an alien symbiote cop crash-lands on Earth and has to hitch a ride abroad a plucky kid, to look for another of its species who is basically a psychopath who likes murdering its hosts. This notably doesn’t happen before it’s caught, which makes me think that the hero may be just a little biased against the criminal…

princessroxana
2 years ago

Thus, Canadian astronauts are no longer free to slaughter other nation’s space travellers before looting their still-warm bodies. Years of smuggling cutlasses into space have all been for naught.

Damn! And I missed out on all that? ☹️

Russell H
Russell H
2 years ago

See also the “JAG in Space” series by Jack Campbell (pseudonym for John G. Hemry, featuring Ensign Paul Sinclair, who is assigned to a US Space Navy ship and tasked with legal matters.  The four-novel series has him involved in courts-martials aboard ship, which usually have him further tasked with investigating the matters in contention.

Paladin Burke
Paladin Burke
2 years ago

What about Asimov’s Lucky Starr series?

dd-b
2 years ago

Always glad to see Doc Smith showing up, of course.

The Tom Corbett, Space Cadet series is clearly about an organization with law-enforcement obligations and powers.

trif
trif
2 years ago

What about detectives, ostensibly from a mundane Earth bound series – complete with long running tv series. who have to investigate a murder on the moon in the far flung future of 2010?

I bring you Dalziel and Pascoe in SPAAAACCCCEEEEE

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One_Small_Step_(novella)

 

 

James Davis Nicoll
2 years ago

33: Huh. Well, I guess if Dick Tracy could go to the Moon….

k_nmi_n
2 years ago

Sibyl Sue Blue by Rosel George Brown

I haven’t read it in forty years, but I remember buying multiple copies and making all my friends read it.

Noah Katz
Noah Katz
2 years ago

Christopher Anvil, Interstellar Patrol 

ashurredly
ashurredly
2 years ago

Tanya Huff’s Peacekeeper trilogy (the follow-up to her Valor books) basically have Torin become a space cop.

Tom K
Tom K
2 years ago

 How about Larry Niven’s Gil Hamilton series, starting with “The Long Arm of Gil Hamilton” – especially after Gil joins ARM (Amalgamated Regional Militia) – psi arms can be useful…

James Davis Nicoll
2 years ago

35: It’s back in print, courtesy Journey Press.

Susan Moskop
Susan Moskop
2 years ago

I remember watching Star Cops on PBS in the early nineties. I had vhs copies of the show that disappered sometime in the subsequent years. But I just discovered I could watch them on YouTube!

Although it’s set in 2027, it’s very much of it’s time in terms of clothing styles and how technology looks. Near future SF is always tricky with that “how do we make it plausible and yet interesting and incredible” problem. I still love it.

Susan Moskop
Susan Moskop
2 years ago

Sorry. Its, not it’s.

D.K.
D.K.
2 years ago

Stellar Ranger (1994) by Steve Perry is a good one.

Terry Karlish
Terry Karlish
2 years ago

Police Your Planet by Lester del Ray.  Also a good study of corruption and machine politics.

Janis Milford
Janis Milford
2 years ago

LCIS – Lunar Crime Scene investigations.  In the vein of CSI but interplanetary

RobMRobM
2 years ago

@8 – Diplomatic Immunity might be the most on point Miles work; or Mountains of Mourning.  Perhaps Komarr could work as well.  

HarryH
HarryH
2 years ago

Asimov’s “caves Of Steel”, and “The Necked Sun”.

Sheri
Sheri
2 years ago

How about Poul Anderson’s Time Patrol and Dominic Flandry?

John_George
2 years ago

@26: Hamilton may well have been first, but I might have said his Captain Future serials predated his Space Patrol series; I am not sure about that.
Also, John W. Campbell, Jr., wrote his Arcot, Wade, and Morey stories starting in 1930 or so (I think) and the first one was law enforcement; two of the three capture the third as an evil air pirate, robbing large aircraft in mid-flight. It’s an entertaining read, showing as it does how people thought air travel might resemble ocean travel in the early days.

willie_mctell
2 years ago

Glad to see mention of Jack Vance.  He used the traditional mystery as the framework for many of his books.  The Alastor novels are mysteries.  As others have mentioned, the Demon Princes and the Galactic Effectuator stories are about crime. Then there are the stories where IPC weasels crop up.   Solving puzzles and finding the culprit is a theme in many Vance stories whether or not they deal directly with crime.  

Then there are Asimov’s Daneel Olivaw stories. 

Cdr. Bowman
Cdr. Bowman
2 years ago

The various “Time Cops” series (Anderson, Piper, I’m sure there are others) were (usually) not in “space,” though, being set in various different “Earths”, although there’s undoubtedly an exception or two to the rule.

Flandry was very much a military intelligence agent; although his investigations often included a “crime,” they were usually espionage or treason; his excursions into “criminal” surroundings were usually along the lines of a cover or something similar.

Anderson did have a short detective series involving a very Holmes-like protagonist who lived and worked in a different universe than his larger series centered on Van Rijn and Flandry.

Marcus Rowland
Marcus Rowland
2 years ago

@47 – Re Guardians of Time etc., It became more and more obvious as the series progressed that the Time Patrol existed to keep the Danellian civilization a few million years in the future from disappearing, and that keeping the intervening periods unchanged was much less important to them. In at least one story they change time to ensure that their future happens, with the time patrol’s intervention being the only change in what should have happened.

Brian Rose
Brian Rose
2 years ago

Nightside City by Lawrence Watt-Evans and its sequel, Realms of Light.

Fred Kiesche
Fred Kiesche
2 years ago

17-18-19: Hal Clement. Needle/Through the Eye of a Needle. Alien detective pursuing a criminal. Detective and criminal are very unique in appearance.

excessivelyperky
2 years ago

Murderbot solves crimes, too, especially if committed against People (loosely defined in this series) they like. 

chip137
2 years ago

 @19: if you mean Iceworld (only reference I can find in ISFDB), the alien is more of a mole — and he’s a chemistry teacher (like Clement), rather than a professional detective. Gives an interesting slant to the story, as one of his few bits of detection requires him to make his own lab gear and determine that a substance that was previously only hypothesized actually exists.

Places in the Darkness, by Chris[topher] Brookmyre, is detection/procedural on a space station; my notes are vague (ISTR it involved the standard trope of conflict between a private investigator and an employee who’s trying to get usable results) but note that it’s massively better than most attempts by mundane writers to do SF. (Brookmyre is one of the leading writers of what’s been called Tartan Noir.)

Stuart Hall
Stuart Hall
2 years ago

Star Cops has just been revived in audio form by Big Finish.

NancyLebovitz
2 years ago

As I recall, in The Stars My Destination, Gully Foyle finds out who’s responsible for a spaceship that didn’t rescue him. The crime happened in space. The detection happened on earth.