Mercedes Lackey’s first trilogy, The Heralds of Valdemar was published in 1987 and ’88. It was followed shortly thereafter by her second and third trilogies, and a series of other series set in Valdemar and elsewhere.
I got my first copy of Arrows of the Queen as a twelfth birthday present, back when I was a socially awkward horse-crazy kid, which means that I was basically the bullseye of the target audience for that work and for a number of the books that followed. And there have been a lot of books about Valdemar—an average of just over one a year since 1987, despite a five-year hiatus from 2003-2008. I think it’s fair to admit that I have stopped being the target audience. My relationship with Valdemar and its Heralds was definitely at its most exciting when I was twelve, but I’m still excited to see them.
Lackey has been building the Kingdom of Valdemar, and the other countries and cultures that occupy the planet Velgarth, through almost continuous attention for the last 27 years. It now constitutes one of the most prolonged ongoing efforts in world-building in the fantasy genre. Lackey’s work has been justly noted for its gender politics, but has also explored history, engineering, educational systems, diplomacy, politics, emergency management, public health, warfare and physics. And, as I noted in my review of Closer to Home, it’s just really fun to read.
We’ll be starting with the Heralds of Valdemar trilogy (Arrows of the Queen, Arrow’s Fall, and Arrow’s Flight), originally published in 1987-88, and then moving on to The Last Herald-Mage trilogy (Magic’s Pawn, Magic’s Promise, and Magic’s Price) and By the Sword. These works are generally too slight to sustain a detailed chapter-by-chapter examination. Instead I’ve divided them into sections more-or-less based around major plot events. I’ll be posting about one section each week. I will be considering both the books themselves and their relationship to late-20th century social history and popular culture. There will be love. There will be snark.
Before we begin, some useful vocabulary for those new to Valdemar:
Velgarth—The planet. It’s named in the prologue of most of the books, but almost no one ever mentions it.
Valdemar—The country most of the novels are set in. It’s significantly better than neighboring countries because its government has a rudimentary set of checks and balances in the form of magic horses.
Companions—Blue-eyed, white, psychic horses that choose people to serve as Valdemar’s political elites, usually when their adolescent angst is at its dramatic peak.
Heralds—The people who have been chosen by Companions. Heralds ride around the kingdom mediating disputes, collecting taxes, assisting in defense, and dispensing justice. Valdemaran law requires that monarchs must also be Heralds, although they usually don’t travel.
The Monarch’s Own—The head Herald, responsible for advising the reigning monarch. This Herald is chosen by a special Companion. He is the best one.
The Council—A group of high-ranking nobles and other officials who advise the monarch, impose taxes, and approve laws. Council decisions are made by majority vote, but can be vetoed by the Monarch and the Monarch’s Own voting together.
Did I miss anything important? Let me know in the comments!
Ellen Cheeseman-Meyer teaches history and reads a lot.
The Valdemar books were pivotal to me as another horsecrazy teenager who felt isolated from my peers. (KEROWYN IS THE BEST!) I gave up reading them in my late teens–I’d mostly outgrown teenage angst and was bored by protagonists who hadn’t–but I still look back at them with fond nostalgia.
Arrows is also significant for being my very first introduction to nonheterosexual people. I remember reading Talia’s story about Vanyel and his bard lover and being certain she’d somehow got the pronouns wrong. I learned a lot from Lackey about tolerance and understanding. Maybe I’ll pick a book up for the reread after all. :)
So does this mean we should go for the first “section” by next Monday, November 3rd?
OH MY GOD.
PLEASEPLEASEPLEASE tell me you’re going to include the Exile series in this! Alberich is one of my favorite fictional characters of all time, and I will cry with happiness if you make this a thing. PLEASE???
They don’t collect taxes – they do gather information that let’s the tax collector there’s something odd he should look into.
I realized they scratch another itch – the good guys are the fantasy equivalent of Doc Smith’s Lensmen.
They’re still ‘to be grabbed and read as quickly as possible’ popcorn books for me!
OH MY GOD.
PLEASEPLEASEPLEASE tell me you’re going to include the Exile series in this! Alberich is one of my favorite fictional characters of all time, and I will cry with happiness if you make this a thing. PLEASE???
Maybe I should clarify that I will be reading these for the first time, hoping to follow along with your reread, :3
The Last Herald-Mage trilogy is still one of my favorite set of books, some-odd years later. I don’t much care for many of the others, besides the Black / White Gryphon, but that trilogy always caught me.
I cane into these with the Mage Winds and was compltely hooked. Can’t wait for this!
Due to the very insistent urgings of a friend I read The Heralds of Valdemar for the first time just a few months ago. This was my first foray into Mercedes Lackey (which is weird considering I grew up not a few miles from where she lives). I like them but you could tell Lackey was a beginning novelist. Do her later books get better?
I bought Arrows of the Queen when it first came out (as an angsty teenager). I read it in a day. Then I reread it the next day, and the next week. I was so her target audience. I’m not as big a Valdemar reader these days (I got annoyed with the Change trilogy, and couldn’t regain the immediate love after that), but I do still read the new books. I just might take a couple of years to get around to them, and they aren’t insta-buy in hardcover anymore.
Along with By the Sword will you address the Tarma and Kethry stories? Those (originally in the Sword and Sorceress anthologies, later sort of adapted into The Oathbound and collected in Oathblood) Those stories are what pulled me in. I like the Valdemar books, but Tarma and Kethry are still my favorite.
@9
They vary quite a bit. Pretty much all are ideal for a teenage reader.
Some are simple popcorn fodder for a more sophisticated reader, some are very very good. One good feature – she doesn’t shy away from putting some of her characters through the wringer, and bad things can happen to good people. Most tend to build on what has come before though.
Brightly Burning is one of the best standalones, along with By The Sword and the Oathbound/Oathbreakers.
The Last Herald Mage trilogy Magic’s Pawn/Promise/Price is probably the strongest in my mind, it has a nice dark edge to it.
Exiles Honor/Valour don’t stand alone well, and the Mage Winds/Mage Storms are really one long story broken into handy chunks.
I like the fact that some of Lackey’s protagonists, Alberich, Tarma and Kethry for example are NOT teenagers coming of age. And unusually for this level of book Lackey is prepared to kill significant characters.
@2 – I’m planning to cover chapters 1-2 of Arrows of the Queen in the next post, coming up 11/3.
Ooh, ooh, ooh. Time to break out my Heralds of Valdemar song cycle tapes. (Wait- do I still have a cassette player?)
1987-88? I was about ten years past perfect target market, but still loved them. (dog crazy substitutes quite well for horse-crazy)
I don’t know if Lackey was the first to have an entire cottage industry — selling song cassettes and Herald-themed jewelry and whatnot — on the side, but she was the first that I was really aware of. I may still have one of those catalogs floating around.
(And could we please get the Peter Beagle cassette released in, well, any other form?)
As much as I don’t connect with them as much as I did as a teenager, I do have to say that THE LAST HERALD MAGE trilogy literally changed my life, by changing my perceptions and my thought processes. I would not be who I am today if I hadn’t read those books.
That said, once I read a completely and utterly accurate summary of MAGIC’S PROMISE that went entirely as follows: “Vanyel: Ow.”
Only that Valdemar books have some of the most fabulous cover art in genre. I can spot those pink ponies from anywhere!
Is this just the first trilogy? If you plan to keep going, there is a distinct possibility that she can write more books faster than you can review them.
@iskander: Jody Lee cover art ftw – she introduced me to all kinds of awesome female authors in the late 80s. Still being used for Mercedes Lackey and Michelle West by DAW today. I love her work, reminds me of Art Deco, Art Nouveau, Alphonse Mucha, etc.
I’ll definitely be following this reread. The Valdemar series was one of my favorites in high school. I own most of the older books up through the Owl Knight trilogy, and I still read every new Valdemar book when it arrives at the library. My favorite is Brightly Burning, with the Vanyel and Talia trilogies not far behind.
While I loved the first two series (Arrows and Heralds) and there have been a few good ones here and there (e.g. By the Sword), the quality fell off sharply after the first few years. Characters began to be one-sided and as soon as you met certain stock characters, you knew what they would be–the betrayer, the mentor, the good at all costs, the scarred/injured one with the heart of gold. A shame really, because the world is very well-realised, just the writing has failed, dismally. I no longer read new ones in the series because the writing quality (or lack of it) is too jarring. If you want to read a series where the writing gets better and better as the story progresses, try Lee & Miller’s Liaden Universe or Bujold’s Miles Vorkosigan series; sadly, not Lackey. That said, I do re-read my favourites of her’s from time to time. Looking forward to your review, should be fun!
Please please please say you will make Vanyel happen sometime in the future. I have no idea if I could deal with these books now, as I’ve outgrown a lot of writing/writing styles in my lifetime, but { # OF DECADES REDACTED } ago, when I was 16, the Last Herald-Mage series redid my head for me and made me a better person — this is undeniable — and I will always love it.
(Last Herald-Mage and Winds; those two series stand out for me. Oath duology a very close second place. I think I was too old for Arrows by the time I was able to obtain it — it never tweaked my heart in the same way.)
@23 – Vanyel is definitely part of my plans.
@@@@@ 24 — Yay!
Tarma and Kethry came first – in the Sword and Sorceress trilogy, they were the gateway to Valdemar…..
I will be rereading along with you… (My second reread – my first was when I introduced my daughter to Arrows of the Queen…)
I have been reading Lackey for a very long time. She does not only live in Valdemar. On my table now I have her latest “Revolution” from “Secret World Chronicals”. I look forward to going back with you.